More Fallout for Star Simpson
September 22nd, 2007
The Boston press is coming down pretty hard on Star Simpson, the MIT sophomore and "artist" who yesterday strolled through Logan airport with a fake bomb and was nearly taken out by security forces. MIT's getting a bit of a black eye as well. [Edited to add: It's not clear that she constructed the device to be a fake bomb, or to look like a bomb; she claims the circuit board with a bunch of wires sticking out from under her sweatshirt was a piece of art she had created to stand out at a career fair -- if true, also a boneheaded move, but not one that rises to the same level as walking into an airport with a device that makes people think you're a suicide bomber. More here.]
I have to wonder what she was smiling about while she was being arraigned? According to the Boston Herald, "[d]uring her arraignment in East Boston, Simpson smiled as her lawyer entered a not guilty plea to possession of a hoax device, a felony with a maximum penalty of five years in prison and a $5,000 fine."
Many locals are also making the "brilliant but not bright" observation (with an emphasis on the "not bright" part). From the same article, verbatim:
- “It makes me angry that police, instead of responding to legitimate emergencies, have to be diverted to deal with morons,” City Councilor John Tobin said. “In this day and age, you can’t play around.”
- “Thankfully, because she followed our directions, she is in a jail cell right now instead of the morgue,” State Police Maj. Scott Pare said.
- The Logan scare was the second MIT-related incident that has created chaos this month. On Sept. 6, a cleanup crew working the banks of the Charles River was burned when it retrieved metallic sodium. Although the exact source of the substance remains under investigation, the annual “sodium drop” is a tradition for MIT students.
- Yesterday, MIT released a statement calling Simpson’s actions “reckless."
People are particularly sensitive about Logan airport, where all four of the 9/11 planes originated: “Enough with the guerrilla art. It’s irresponsible. . . . What did she actually think was going to happen?” asked Juliette Kayyem, undersecretary of Homeland Security.To Alyson Low, whose 28-year-old sister Sara was a flight attendant on one of the planes hijacked six years ago, yesterday’s drama was “painful” to watch. “She had better be given a jail cell surrounded by the photographs of all the people who left that airport and never came back,” Low said. “With freedom comes responsibility. And she showed none.”Well put.



re: More Fallout for Star Simpson
*sigh* What bomb? What "under her sweatshirt?" Look at the photos -- LEDs in a star arrangement, held with Scotch tape on the outside of her sweatshirt.
The real story here is the police overreaction after the blinkie circuit was found harmless. Boston is getting very good at police overreaction.
re: More Fallout for Star Simpson
Click on the link and see a picture of the alleged "fake bomb".
"Many locals are also making the "brilliant but not bright" observation (with an emphasis on the "not bright" part)."
A big part of what this has been all about - petty, anti-intellectual jealousy.
re: More Fallout for Star Simpson
You know what else comes with responsibility? RESPONSIBILITY!
All these people over-reacting to Simpson, including but not limited to the district attorney, all of the local news, the police and even the nimrod at the information booth who started it all have abrogated their responsibilities.
The person at the info booth should have figured out that REAL bombs can be much more easily hidden in the thousands of briefcases that passengers carry with them every day instead of a blinky bread-board on a girl's chest.
The police should have realized that the report by the info booth person was suspect and probably a false alarm to begin with (after all, they have NEVER had a real alarm at any airport in the USA, but they have killed people in false alarms like the guy in Miami who was shot in the back running AWAY from the plane).
The DA should have realized that everybody else over-reacted and that not only would prosecuting Simpson be a waste of yet more tax dollars and paint his office as a bunch of political CYAers, it also sends a message that conformity is more important than free-thinking. A message that, if taken seriously, will kill any chance we have as a nation to maintain world leadership in the sciences.
And of course the news reporting - content to parrot the line "hoax bomb" long after it had been well established it was no such thing. The fourth estate has failed miserably in its duty to frame the issue in thoughtful manner, instead succumbing to sensationalism and hype, truth and rational thinking be damned.